Could you survive as a one car household?

DrivewayWhen Tony and I were planning our move to North Carolina over two years ago, we had to make a very difficult decision about transportation. At the time, we each drove an older, used car. Both of our cars were doing okay at the time, but they had over 100,000 miles on them. We knew it was only a matter of time before we started having car problems, and we didn’t want it to happen after we moved.

We made the decision to share one reliable car instead of having two older, used cars. Our decision dictated a lot of the lifestyle decisions we made as we planned our move. We found an apartment close to campus so Tony could take a shuttle to class, invested in a AAA membership to ensure that we’d have access to towing and roadside assistance, and chose a new car with a 10 year, 100,000 mile warranty to ensure that our car would be reliable for as long as possible.

It’s worked out extremely well for us. Here’s a rough estimate of the money we save by sharing a car:

  • Car payment: $250 a month
  • Car insurance: $50-$85 a month
  • Gas: $50-$75 a month
  • Registration/taxes: $150 a year
  • Oil changes: $60 a year
  • Tires: $400 every two years or $200 a year

It’s really amazing how much you can spend on owning a car, and most people never even consider if they could live with just one. Depending on your situation, it may be easier than you think. Here are some things to think about if you’re considering life with one vehicle:

How “walkable” is your neighborhood?

Do you live hear a grocery store, library, and other places you need to go regularly? You can get your neighborhood’s “walk score” to determine how close you are to these places. If you’re living somewhere with a low walk score, making a move to a more walkable neighborhood and downsizing to one vehicle could save you quite a bit of money.

Is public transportation a possibility for you or your spouse?

Take a look at your city’s bus schedule and map to see if either of you could commute to and from work using public transportation.

What about carpooling?

Ask around at your job to see if anyone lives in your neighborhood or drives through it on their way into the office. You might be able to throw in some money for gas and ride with them. If carpooling with co-workers isn’t possible, consider a service like or to find other carpoolers around you.

What’s your schedule?

Do you and your spouse have work schedules that would allow one of you to drop the other one off on the way to work? This is sometimes what Tony and I do if he needs the car for some reason during the day. I’m working all day, so the car would just be sitting in the parking lot at my office anyway. It’s no problem for him to drop me off, run his errands, and pick me up in the evening.

Be careful, though.

If you decide to downsize to one car, proper maintenance becomes even more important. Consider lowering your insurance deductible if you don’t have a healthy emergency fund, keep up with regular maintenance like oil changes and tire rotations, and look into adding car rental to your insurance plan to make sure you won’t be stranded in the event of an accident.

Whatever you do, don’t write it off as impossible without considering your options. There are a ton of financial, environmental, and health benefits to becoming a one-car household. With a little planning, organization, and lifestyle shifting, it might be easier for you than you think.

Photo by acrider

6 thoughts on “Could you survive as a one car household?

  1. Cathy

    We went the summer without a second car when my husband’s car he has driven for 13 years died for the last time – well, over $3,000 in repairs. It can definitely be done. He rode his bike 8 miles to and from work everyday. I will say though, it is a challenge for a family to have one car, especially when your children become teens and you live in the Chicagoland suburbs where classes and events are scattered everywhere and the winters aren’t so great. I do admire families that work with one car – many in my homeschooling group make it work. For us, it wasn’t worth it right now.
    .-= Cathy´s last blog ..A New Rheumatoid Arthritis Store =-.

  2. Kacie

    We have una coche. Ever since Shane’s old car kicked the bucket back in Feb 08, we’ve made it work with one. Even though we could probably afford to get a second car, we just don’t want one.

    Shane takes public transit to work and it’s walkable. I pick him up from the train stop in the evenings just to be nice. heh.

    I do think if/when we move to another city, we’ll need to get a second car.
    .-= Kacie´s last blog ..Save money on shoes by fixing the ones you have =-.

  3. The Non-Student

    Sharing a car has made life easier for us, but we’re in a big city and rarely even need the one. We walk and take the subway practically all the time. But when we do, it’s nice to have and it makes time in the car a special time to be together, even if we’re just going to Target!
    .-= The Non-Student´s last blog ..Sharing is Hot =-.

  4. brittany

    I know it isn’t doable for everyone (particularly those in smaller cities or ‘burbs or with families) but my life has been so much less stressful with no car at all! (This is year No. 3, I think!) I like it so much and it makes my life so much easier that I think I’ll have to always live in a big city with adequate public transportation to make it doable, although if I ever have kids I imagine I’ll have to break down and buy one again. Here’s hoping hybrids are cheaper by then!

    People used to ask me how I could afford to live in NYC — “It’s so expensive there!” I used to tell them, well, add up all the costs you pay for your car that I don’t have, that’s how I do it!
    .-= brittany´s last blog ..I know, this is getting old. =-.

  5. Pingback: Hassled Home Life » Blog Archive » One Car Living. Are you possible?

Comments are closed.